Canadas Controversial New Mortgage Rules

Real Estate News Article

< Back

Canadas Controversial New Mortgage Rules

Written By: Jim Adair
Monday, December 04, 2017

Canadas banking regulators think that home buyers are spending too much money and taking on too much debt. Starting on Jan. 1, 2018, it will be tougher for anyone taking out a new mortgage from a federally regulated lender to qualify for a mortgage. That includes people who want to renew a mortgage from a different lender than their current provider.

To qualify, borrowers must be able to pass a "stress test" and prove that they could afford to pay the current mortgage rate plus two percentage points. The rule applies to federally regulated lenders, which includes the major banks. Those who are renewing an existing mortgage are exempt from the stress-test provision if they dont switch lenders, but if they want to shop around for a new rate theyll have to pass the test for the new provider.

Another option is to go to lenders that are not governed by the federal regulator, such as credit unions and private lenders.

"The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions OSFI is keenly aware of the potential risks caused by high household indebtedness across Canada and by high real estate prices in some markets," said superintendent Jeremy Rudin in a speech to the Economic Club of Canada.

"We are not waiting to see those risks crystalize in rising arrears and defaults before we act. Rather, we are adapting our standards to new developments."

Benjamin Tal of CIBC Capital Markets says the change "reduces the purchasing power of typical buyers by close to 20 per cent, and we estimate that no less than 10 to 15 per cent of mortgage originations will be impacted."

Scotiabanks Adrienne Warren also estimates that 10 per cent "of current loan applications would no longer qualify under the new rules. The overall impact on sales, however, is likely to be smaller, as some potential buyers could choose to purchase a lower-priced home, while others may be able to extend their amortization period or opt for a lower variable mortgage rate in order to extend their buying power."

The OSFI decisions have come under heavy criticism from the real estate and mortgage industries, as well as other economists.

Jim MacGee, a fellow at the C.D. Howe Institute, wrote in a memo to Finance Minister Bill Morneau that the new rules unduly limit competition among lenders. "In response to concerns that simply adding two percentage points to the quoted mortgage rate would encourage borrowers to shift from five-year fixed mortgages to shorter-term mortgages with variable rates, OSFI requires lenders to use the higher of the rate offered by the lender plus two per cent or the average five-year fixed rate posted by the six largest banks. This lowers the incentives for a lender to offer a low interest rate to help a borrower qualify for a mortgage."

He says that "borrowers with high debt-to-income ratios may find that they can only qualify for a renewal with their existing lender. This removes the option to shop for a better rate and limits borrowers bargaining power on renewal. This is likely to result in higher rates for borrowers who already face high debt payments >As many as one in six people renewing their mortgage "could be trapped at their existing bank because they cant pass the stress test at another lender. And if a bank knows you cant leave, you can bet your boots theyll use that as leverage to serve up subpar renewal rates," wrote RateSpy.com founder Robert McLister in a column for the Globe Mail.

The Fraser Institute points out that the rate of residential mortgage arrears in Canada, where the borrower is more than 90 days behind in payments, is "virtually unchanged from 2002 and hasnt exceeded 0.45 per cent, even during the 2009 financial crisis, when the U.S. rate of arrears neared five per cent."

Neil Mohindra, public policy consultant at the Fraser Institute, says the "stress test for financially sound home buyers is unnecessary and will do more harm than good -- Canadian home buyers will pay the price."

His study on the regulations concludes that homebuyers may need to settle for less desirable homes than the ones they prefer, and that they "may seek out less-regulated mortgage finance companies, which are funded by private investors and charge higher interest rates."

It may also prompt people to choose shorter-term variable loans, which are more vulnerable to rate fluctuations than longer-term fixed-rate mortgages.

"It is one thing to act before a problem emerges and another to search for a problem where it does not exist," write Sean Spear and Jane Londerville in a paper for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute. "This is regulation-making in search of a problem."

They say the policy "also conflicts with the intent of other policies, such as the current governments pledge to significantly increase the Home Buyers Plan and make it more flexible for first-time buyers." The plan allows buyers to borrow funds from their Registered Retirement Savings Plan.

"This is the type of policy incoherence that we see across federal housing policy," write Spear and Londerville.



Copyright© 2017 Realty Times®. All Rights Reserved

Updated: Monday, December 11, 2017

Purple Power: How To Use Panto...
Seeing a whole lot of purple recently“ Its not an homage to Prince. Its Pantones Color...

The Introverts Guide to Hostin...
So you somehow got roped into hosting a holiday get-together this year, which means dozens o...

Get The Look: Transitional-Sty...
Transitional >The Basics: Mixing Old and NewFundamentally, transitional >Often ...

Copyright ©2017Realty Times®. All Rights Reserved

Housing Rebound: Factors to Consider
In Miami we have had an incredible year of growth with an ever shrinking supply of condos...

Hoteliers Buy Versace Mansion at Auction
Gindi Family and Nakash Family of New York were the winners of the auction for Casa Casuarina...

Stunning Estate for Sale on Allison Island
Allison Island is one of the man made islands comprising Miami Beach. One half of the island...

Avant Garde and Luxurious Penthouse on Fisher Island
Fisher Island is home to some of the highest net worth individuals in Miami. It is a private...

6000 Indian Creek, Condominium Spotlight
6000 Indian Creek is a Sieger Suarez project that was completed in 2007 and consists of...

$35 Million Buys you THIS on Star Island
$35 Million for a home on Star Island is par for the course in Miami Beach real estate....

Development Update
It is looking like a dusty winter season in Miami, with all the construction rapidly underway,...

North Bay Road Charm, 4330 North Bay Road
4330 North Bay Road is a stunning example of Mediterranean architecture in Miami Beach....

Best Home Improvements for Resale Value
It could not be a better time for a homeowner to list their home for sale in Miami. The...

Biscayne Gets a New Development
The Melo Group of developers acquired 601 NE 23rd St last year and have conceived of 23...

520 West Ave Residence 2301
520 West Avenue is home of the Bentley Bay. Bentley Bay is comprised of two modern towers...

Spice 2013, Guide 101
Miami Spice is a program whereby most of the restaurants in the city encourage people to...

Hollywood has a New Hotel
Margaritaville Hollywood is coming to Hollywood Beach and is likely to completely alter...

Sustainable Waterfront Home on Normandy Isle, 1.85 Million
Rarely on the market do we find completely sustainable, off the grid, homes in Miami Beach....

Housing Inventory on the Rise at the Close of Summer
The Wallstreet Journal released numbers via Realtor.com regarding the inventory of available...

Warm Spanish Style Home Listed on the Sunset Islands
1844 W. 23rd Street is listed on the Miami Beach luxury real estate marketplace for $11...

Former Gansevoort Getting Complete Eco-Renovation
Last year the Perry Hotel, formerly the Gansevoort, was purchased for $230 million. The...

Affordable Luxury Waterfront on Hibiscus Island
A home that is considered affordable in Miami terms for waterfront is generally between...

Bart Reines New Masterpiece Released on the Market
Bart Reines is one of the worlds most impressive modern architects living, and he has just...

New Listing on La Gorce Island
98 La Gorce Court has just been listed for sale. This over 7800 square foot home with 8...